Sign up to get new listings emailed daily! JOIN SIGN IN
Tarah Sheteron
Chairman's Club 2025
REALTOR®, Associate Broker in MI - Licensed in MI & IN
(269) 876-9276
Facebook Icon LinkedIn Icon Instagram Icon Zillow Icon VCard Icon 

As a first time home buyer, I was feeling like a "deer in headlights" at times. Tarah was very helpful introducing me to properties and in proposing an offer. She kept constant communication, reminding me of deadlines that had to be met. I would absolutely recommend her to friends and family!

Tyler, Osceola IN | Home Buyer

Tarah Sheteron was a pleasure to work with.

Kate B., Cassopolis, MI | Home Seller

We had an outstanding experience working with Tarah Sheteron! From the very beginning, she demonstrated professionalism, attention to detail, and a level of responsiveness that set her apart. Within the first week of listing our home, Tarah generated three strong offers—two of them well over asking price with excellent terms. Her strategy, market knowledge, and preparation made all the difference in creating that kind of momentum.What impressed us just as much was her ability to guide us through purchasing our next home. We found ourselves in a competitive bidding war, and thanks to Tarah’s expertise and negotiation skills, we secured the home we wanted. She knows how to position her clients to win. Throughout the entire process, Just as important, she operates with strong ethics and integrity, which gave us confidence and peace of mind. We recommend Tarah to anyone looking to buy or sell a home, and we would absolutely work with her again in the future!!!!

Mike & Lisa Casey, Cassopolis, MI to South Bend, IN | Home Seller

Tarah was great again! I used her to sell a property two years ago and that process was so smooth that I knew when we were in the market to buy that she would be our choice to go with. I reached out earlier than when I previously told her we would be on the hunt and she jumped right into action setting up multiple viewings within a few days. She kept us in the loop every step of the way from the beginning offer to the closing date. She was knowledgeable about the market and area and willing to answer any questions we had. Would definitely recommend Tarah, whether you're selling your home or in the market for a new one!

William Lee, Three Rivers, MI | Home Buyer

Tarah is fantastic. I can not imagine working with somebody else. She made the whole process easy and enjoyable. Very friendly aknowlegable and professional. I am recommnding her to everybody

Margaret Dobrowolska, Granger IN | Home Seller

She was great! Professional, punctual, intelligent, beautiful, tall.. The total opposite of me ?.. She worked around my schedule. Gave me any information I asked for.. In all seriousness she was a good person and agent.. And made a difficult situation easy for me.. A

Gabriel Franco, Elkhart, IN | Home Buyer

Tarah was prompt and professional. Very informative throughout the process and exceeded all expectations. Would highly recommend!

Taira Nelson, Granger, IN | Home Seller

Tarah is fantastic. She is very helpful and knowlegable. We felt very comfortable with her.

Margaret Dobrowolska, Granger, IN | Home Buyer

Love Tarah! She listened to what we wanted and thoughtfully helped us through the negotiation process. She was always available for showings and prompt in preparing offers. Would highly recommend!

Taira Nelson, Granger, IN | Home Buyer

We can't than Tarah enough for helping us sell our home and buy a new one! Her expertise, responsivenes, and dedication made the entire process smooth and stress-free. She kept us informed every single step of the way and truly went above and beyond to make sure everything worked out perfectly.

Crystal and Ron H., Indiana | Home Seller

Having bought or sold 7 homes in the past 50 years Tarah is far and away the best agent we have ever worked with.

Karl L. Erickson, Edwardsburg michigan | Home Buyer

Tarah went above and beyond to find us our dream home. Her knowledge of the market led us to several properties, finally keying in on the perfect home. Not only did Tarah sell us our dream home she made the sale of our existing home extremely pleasant as well. Every aspect of the process was clearly communicated and executed to satisfaction. A few hiccups were also overcome with her extensive knowledge of the market area. I would recommend Tarah to anyone in the Michiana area looking to purchase or sell a property.

Ron Halfman, Elkhart, IN formerly Edwardsburg, MI | Home Buyer

Tarah Sheteron did a wonderful job listing, marketing and closing the sale of our house. She overcame many obstacles from the market and the process to close on the house. I would highly recommend Tarah to sell your home.

RJ Wildeman, Niles, MI | Home Seller

Thank you very much Tarah for your hard work and dedication it was awesome!! Will highly recommend family and friends for your services!

Angee, Niles michigan | Home Seller

She was great, attentive, responsive to my messages quickly

Sally Muscat, Edwardsburg, MI | Home Seller

Tarah Sheteron stayed on top of the search process and was an excellent communicator during the home search and then purchasing process. We had some unusual stumbling blocks thrown into our path, and Tarah handled every single one with grace and determination. She kept me informed, and I could not have asked for a better realtor. I would recommend Tarah to anyone, whether they are buying in Indiana or Michigan, and if I ever have need of a realtor again, I will definitely call Tarah!

Mary Pringle, Edwardsburg, MI | Home Buyer

absolute pleasure working with tarah. thank you for everything

scott wenger, cassopolis michigan | Home Buyer

She was very polite, helpful and full of knowledge of the area. Helped me and my family set up services and even helped me move some boxes!! 10 out of 10 would definitely go through her again in the future. I would Definitely recommend her to anyone I know moving into the area. I wish I could give her 10 stars!!

Shawn Moore, Niles, MI | Home Buyer

Hi, I'm Karen Swoape and my husband Tad and I had Tarah for our realtor. She was very helpful and stuck by us right to the end. If we ever had a question she would find an answer for us, if she didn't know, she was so respectful and funny, very down to earth, made us feel very comfortable selling our home, we can't say enough great things about her, we were very lucky and we are very happy selling our house. Thank you Tarah for helping us start our new journey. Karen and Tad Swoape.

Tad Swoape, Karen Swoape | Home Seller

Tarah was absolutely amazing. She was highly professional, but was very personable and listened to our wants and needs. She went above and beyond. We have bought and sold several houses over the years and she has been the best realtor we have ever worked with!! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!

Diane and Dave, Niles, MI | Home Seller

Tarah was fantastic throughout the process of selling our home, walking us through step by step and making us feel comfortable and informed throughout. Would highly recommend her to anyone I know.

Dan Smith, Elkhart, IN | Home Seller

Tarah is very smart and professional. She works very hard for me regardless of whether I am buying a new home or selling one.

Cyndi Smith, Osceola, Indiana | Home Seller

Tarah is an amazing, competent, reliable realtor. I was very impressed by her multitasking abilities during the tough negotiation stage of the sale of my home and purchase of my new home. Tarah's strength netted top dollar for both myself and my seller and protected my interests in the purchase of my new home. All sides won, and love is great when it is shared.

Becky & Mattie Daniels, Cassopolis, MI | Home Seller

As a first time buyer Tarah was very informative and willing to guide me in the right path of choices. I felt very confident in decisions made after speaking about my concerns. She was willing to put in off the clock time and work late for us which we were very thankful for!

Mattie Daniels, Elkhart Indiana | Home Buyer

Tarah was phenomal to work with. She was helpful every step of the way, from the initial contact all the way through the close. I appreciated the fact she was available by phone, email, or text whenever I had a question or concern. It was my first time selling a home and she made the process seamless. I would recommend her to anyone looking to sell their home based on her knowledge, expertise and overall demeanor.

William Lee, Cassopolis, MI | Home Seller

I worked with this Beautiful Lady before and she is extremely great at what she does,I would refer her to everyone I come in contact with that is wanting to sell there home or become a home owner.

Rosa Howell, Elkhart Indiana | Home Buyer

Tarah has an incredible depth of knowledge. We are first-time homebuyers and she was able to effectively explain each step of the process. She is incredibly responsive and accommodating for our schedule.

Allyssa Emery, South Bend | Home Buyer

I recently listed my home with Tarah Sheteron, it was a wonderful experience. Tarah is extremely knowledgeable, patient, and was on point throughout the sale. She went above and beyond when selling my home, any questions, concerns, or obstacles I encountered Tarah guided me through.

Gretchen Neumeier, Marcellus, MI | Home Seller

Tarah was wonderful! She had prompt responses to all forms of communication and researched every property we looked at to ensure she had all the answers to our questions. Tarah made sure our needs were met within our budget. She was beyond patient with our changing needs and was always glad to help. Her cheerful demeanor was an added bonus to her wonderful client care! We will definitely buy another house from her and highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell!

Brian Bosler, Niles, MI | Home Buyer

Tarah did a tremendous job! She takes great pride in her craft and represents herself with great professionalism. I would strongly recommended Tarah to friends and family for any real estate matters.

Dan Purlee Edwardsburg | Home Buyer

Tarah is simply amazing. I am a first time home buyer. Tarah made the process very simple and she knew the area well! She answered all my tedious questions and did not get annoyed about them either. Tarah is also very personable and very communicative, which I appreciated and still appreciate so much. She always got back to me in a timely manner if she wasn't available when I reached out to her. Whenever I showed her a house I was interested in seeing, she would get it right on our schedule and did not wait on it! She was focused on finding me a home and making sure I was and am happy with it! If I move again, I will definitely be reaching out to Tarah!!

Jourdan Thompson | Home Buyer

Tarah did an excellent job! She is organized, professional, and is good at what she does! I would strongly recommend Tarah to anyone looking to buy or sell.

Dan Purlee Edwardsburg | Home Seller

From the initial contact and requesting help finding a home, Tarah was there to help! She got right to work and started finding places for us to look at. Within just a couple of weeks we were able to find the perfect place and get an offer accepted. The whole process was smooth sailing and couldn't have went any better! Thank you!

Jesse & Ryan, Cassopolis, MI | Home Buyer

I appreciate an agent who is knowledgeable about the local area. And is upfront and honest about what she sees in the house/area but is easy to discuss issues with without being pushy. Highly recommended.

Dave Mc. Niles MI | Home Buyer

Tarah was very professional and communication was the key. She made us feel like our listing mattered. She was excellent with timely communication back and forth. She always kept us in the loop with what was going on with our listing.Thank you Tarah for getting the job done even when situations became challenging and difficult. We would recommend Tarah Sheteron.

Jack and Joni Bartoszek, Granger, IN | Home Seller

Great to work with. Friendly and respectful

John Hunt | Home Seller

Thanks again for the seamless and stress-free transition with selling the property! May the best and brightest unfold in your near future...Much respect and gratitude,Chad

Chad Robinson, Buchanan | Home Seller

I've worked with Tarah in the past and she was really helpful the first time around when i was at a young age under 30 , and she was great and respectful and very knowledgeable. So when selling this house and purchasing a new one it was a no brainer to go with Tarah again. Tarah seems to go about doing everything the right way and thats what makes her so great to work with. Tarah is a motivated employee and just seems to get things done. She has worked with some friends and family of mine and everyone always seems to get what they want/need. Highly recommend.

Randy Bartrum , Edwardsburg | Home Buyer

I met Tarah and knew she was the exact person to take care of everything. Tarah has an awesome personality and knows her business. I have already recommended Tarah to family and friends Tarah is a very professional an classy lady, alot of integrity, she went above and beyond and didn't have to. I have already recommended Tarah to family and friends

Sandy Snyder, Mishawaka, IN | Home Buyer

Tarah was awesome to work with, she listened to our needs, was very professional and always returned our calls, emails or text messages promptly. I would definitely use her again and would recommend her to others. It was a very good experience working with Tarah from the beginning to end.

Danny&Tammy Cassopolis | Home Seller

Tarah was the perfect person for me. She totally understood my needs and everything went very smoothly.

Evelyn Aiello, Niles | Home Seller

Tarah was always available to answer my questions or followed up promptly. I hope to work with Tarah for all my real estate needs in the future.

Justine Webb, South Bend, IN | Home Seller

Tarah did an exceptional job helping to locate our new home and negotiated a very good deal. She is an ultimate professional and give her my highest recommendation.

Michael Crist, Middlebury | Home Buyer

In my eyes, Tarah Sheteron is as close you can get to a perfect realtor! She is very self-less and always puts her clients first. I highly recommend her to first time homebuyers, she pays attention to detail and is understandable to any and all questions you may have. I will only be using Tarah for all future home purchases. The best of the best.

Taylor Strauss, South Bend | Home Buyer

Tarah was an outstanding agent from start to finish! She is so knowledgeable and professional with the right touch of personality to make things flow smoothly. :)

Randi, michigan | Home Seller

Tarah was quick to respond when we decided to list our home. She was helpful with suggestions on things we could do to show the house better as well as some that weren't necessary. She knows her stuff and considering our house was sold so quickly, she helped make the process smooth and quick!

Heather Cavinder | Home Seller

Tarah Sheteron was very knowledgeable and was patient with the other party when they made many requests. Made the sale as easy as possible on us and went above and beyond to tend to our needs and the needs of the buyers. Her experience in the field helped when we needed contractors/inspectors and she was able to explain the process well. She had a positive attitude and mindset which kept us confident, at ease and ultimately made it a pleasurable experience! Would definitely recommend!

Isaiah, Granger | Home Seller

Tarah Sheteron was an amazing agent to work with and if I had to do the process all over again then I would gladly choose her again.

Daimon Cavinder, South Bend | Home Buyer

Tarah was nothing short of amazing from start to finish. In the midst of an extremely challenging market, she persisted and found us our dream home. We couldn’t be happier with her effort and the results! We would recommend her to anyone!

Susan and Wayne | Home Buyer

A true professional, all agents should take a page from her book.very approachable, knowledgeable, and attentive to your needs. Would recommend her to anyone selling or buying a house.

Chris, Middlebury | Home Buyer

Tarah was SO patient with our family! We were looking for a very specific property and it took years of hunting to find it. Tarah willingly stayed in the process with us the whole time through a number of ups and downs. I'm thrilled to say that we finally did find a home that fit all our needs and she negotiated a purchase process that also had ups and downs. She remained committed and involved through every hurdle. We've now been living on our beautiful property for nearly two years and we have Tarah's patience and commitment to thank for it!

Tara wa awesome... Really helped us out on our first buy ever... We didn't know the process... She helped us every step of the way... We walked away with a deal of a lifetime....our dream home! Ty Tara ur the best!!!

Tarah was EXTREMELY helpful when we purchased our first home. We had a very difficult closing experience and she was there on our side through the whole thing. She made sure that everything stayed on track and ended up how it was supposed to be. She was great throughout the entire process!

Tarah worked with my husband and I this year to buy 2 houses. She was very respectful of both our working hours and very prompt with her responses. A joy to work with!

Tarah was very helpful throughout the entire process of buying my house. I knew nothing about the Edwardsburg area and Tarah was able to refer me to the specialists needed in inspecting the house and land. Even to this day, I know if I had any questions, Tarah would be more than willing to help me in any way possible.

She is professional and keeps us informed as we move through the process. She is very good at answering any and all questions that we have. I would definitely recommend her to anyone who is in the market to buy a house.

Tarah Sheteron is the best of all agents in this area. She is extremely knowledgeable and helped us find the best home for us. She helped point out things that were not properly done in homes or things that were done carelessly. I would never trust anyone else in helping us purchase a home. Tarah is an amazing real estate agent and I promise you will not be disappointed in her service and attitude. She was one of the most enjoyable people with whom I have had the pleasure of doing business. Tarah is very knowledgeable, professional, and courteous. I can say with 100 percent conviction that no one will ever be disappointed with Tarah on their side of their real estate transaction. Not only was she knowledgeable, she responds very quickly, and stands behind her word and the people around her. She is the best!

Tarah was helpful, patient, and understanding in our home search process. I would highly recommend her to anyone buying or selling a house.

Tarah was very dedicated and thoughtful when obtaining houses for us to look at. New listings were sent in record time taking into consideration what we had asked for without alot of hubbub in wasting time on homes that she knew would be outside of those requirements, which was very important to us. We knew each time she showed a house it could be the one as she had worked hard to make sure it was honestly the home for us. Her knowledge and experience was a blessing!

Note: a subscription to the Do Not Call list does not apply when requesting information from our company.

Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 05/30/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 05/30/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Sat 05/30/2026 11:43:34 AM EST) or MichRic (Michigan Regional Information Center) (last updated Sat 05/30/2026 11:38:29 AM EST) or NIRA MLS (last updated Sat 05/30/2026 11:34:47 AM EST) or IRMLS (last updated Sat 05/30/2026 11:42:17 AM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Cressy & Everett Real Estate may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility

Agency License Information: Cressy & Everett Real Estate is licensed in the states of Indiana and Michigan.



Agent License Information: Tarah Sheteron is licensed to sell real estate in the states of Indiana and Michigan.

Login to My Homefinder

Pixel